Posts

Showing posts from January, 2013

China Bank v. CA, Gotianuy Digest

China Bank v. CA, Gotianuy Digest G.R. No. 140687 December 18, 2006 Ponente: Phil. SC Justice Chico-Nazario Facts:  1. The case stems from a complaint for a recovery of sums of money and annulment of sales ofreal property and shares of stocks filed by Jose Gotianuy against his son-in-law George Dee and his daughter Mary Margaret Dee. 2. Gotianuy accused his daughter of stealing his properties, US Dollar deposits with Citybank amounting to P35M and $864,000. Margaret Dee obtained these amounts through check issued by Citybank naming her as a co-payee of Gotianuy. She allegedly deposited the checks with petitioner bank. Gotianuy died during the pendency of the case and was substituted by his daughter Elizabeth. 3. Subsequently, employees of China Bank were sent subpoena to testify re:bank  deposits of Margaret Dee but petitioner invoked RA 1405 (Bank Secrecy Law). The lower court held that the disclosure of the name only of a depositor does not constitute a viol...

PNB v. Pike Digest

PNB v. Pike G.R. No. 157845 September 20, 2005 Ponente: Phil. SC Justice Chico-Nazario Facts: The petitioner PNB allowed a representative of Defendant (his talent manager) to withdraw from his dollar account with the use of a pre-signed withrdawal slip. Issue: Whether or not the bank is liable HELD: Yes. PNB was held liable due to the negligence of its employees in allowing the unauthorized withdrawal. This was shown by the lackadaisical attitude of its employees in treating Pike's US dollar account, an act which resulted to the loss of $7,500. Such warrants for the award of damages. The slips used were in breach of the standard operating procedure of the bank in the ordinary and usual course of business. Even if it is the employees who are negligent, the bank's liability as the obligor is not merely vicarious but primary since banks are expected to exercise the degree of diligence in the selection and supervision of their employees.

People v. Navaja Digest 220 SCRA 624 GR. No. 104044

People v. Navaja G.R. No 104044 March 30, 1993 Ponente: Davide, Jr., J Disputable presumption: Suppression of Evidence Facts: 1. The Accused Alexander Navaja was convicted of the crime of selling a prohibited drug, 'shabu' under RA 6425. The authorities set up a buy bust operation but he managed to elude arrest after the transaction. Accused was subsequently arrested during a hearing of the Habeas Corpus case filed by his mother, about a year after. 2. In his appeal the accused contended that the court erred in convicting him as only one of the witnesses among 5 (of the policemen who accosted him) were presented by the prosecution. Issue: Whether or not the non-presentation of the other witnesses gave rise to the  presumption of suppression of evidence HELD: The non-presentation of the corroborative witnesses did not constitute suppression of evidence and such would not be fatal the prosecution's case. The rule is settled that the adverse pre...

Sample Excuse Letter for Student Absence Due to Illness

Image
Excuse Letter for Student Absence Due to Illness Dread writing an excuse letter for your child's school absence? Whether it is due to a sudden bout of the flu, a lingering cough, or an unexpected medical checkup, submitting a formal, respectful excuse letter is a mandatory requirement for almost every school in the Philippines. To help you save time and ensure your letter gets properly approved by the class adviser or principal, here is a clean, ready-to-use template you can easily customize. Here is a standard, easy-to-use sample format for an excuse letter. This document is typically used when a student misses classes due to an illness, medical checkup, or recovery period. --------------------------------------------------------- [ Insert Date ] [ Insert Principal or Teacher's Name ] [ Insert School Name ] [ Insert School Address ] Dear Sir/Madame [ Insert Teacher's Last Name ]: Please excuse my son/daughter, [ Insert Child's Full Name ], from his/her classes la...

Cruz v. Villasor Digest

Cruz v. Villasor  G.R. L-32213 November 26, 1973 Ponente: Esguerra, J.: Facts: 1. The CFI of Cebu allowed the probate of the last will and testament of the late Valenti Cruz. However, the petitioner opposed the allowance of the will alleging that it was executed through fraud, deceit, misrepresentation, and undue influence. He further alleged that the instrument was executed without the testator having been informed of its contents and finally, that it was not executed in accordance with law. 2. One of the witnesses, Angel Tevel Jr. was also the notary before whom the will was acknowledged. Despite the objection, the lower court admitted the will to probate on the ground that there is substantial compliance with the legal requirements of having at least 3 witnesses even if the notary public was one of them. Issue: Whether or not the will is valid in accordance with Art. 805 and 806 of the NCC HELD: NO. The will is not valid. The notary public cannot be cons...

Nera v. Rimando Digest

Nera v. Rimando  G.R. L-5971 February 27, 1911 Ponente: Carson, J.: 'Test of Presence' Facts: 1. At the time the will was executed, in a large room connecting with a smaller room by a doorway where a curtain hangs across, one of the witnesses was in the outside room when the other witnesses were attaching their signatures to the instrument. 2. The trial court did not consider the determination of the issue as to the position of the witness as of vital importance in determining the case. It agreed with the ruling in the case of Jaboneta v. Gustillo that the alleged fact being that one of the subscribing witnesses  was in the outer room while the signing occurred in the inner room, would not be sufficient to invalidate the execution of the will. 3. The CA deemed the will valid. Issue: Whether or not the subscribing witness was able to see the testator and other witnesses in the act of affixing their signatures. HELD: YES The Court is unanimous in...

Garcia v. Lacuesta Digest

Garcia v. Lacuesta  G.R. L-4067 November 29, 1951 Ponente: Paras, C.J. Facts: 1. The CA disallowed the probate of the will of Antero Mercado dated Jan 1943. The said will was written in Ilocano dialect. 2. The will appears to have been signed by Atty. Florentino Javier who wrote the name of the testator followed below by 'A ruego del testador' and the name of Florentino Javier. In effect, it was signed by another although under the express direction of the testator. This fact however was not recited in the attestation clause. Mercado also affixed a cross on the will. 3. The lower court admitted the will to probate but this order was reversed by the Court of Appeals on the ground that the attestation failed to recite the facts surrounding the signing of the testator and the witnesses.  Issue: Whether or not the attestation clause in the will is valid HELD: NO the attestation is fatally defective for its failure to state that Antero or the testator cau...

Matias v. Salud Digest

Matias vs. Salud G.R. L-10907 June 29, 1957 Ponente: Concepcion, J. Facts:  1. This case is an appeal from a CFI Cavite order denying the probate of the will of Gabina Raquel. The document consist of 3 pages and it seems that after the attestation clause, there appears the siganture of the testatrix 'Gabina Raquel', alongside is a smudged in violet ink claimed by the proponents as the thumbmark allegedly affixed by the tetratrix. On the third page at the end of the attestation clause appears signatures on the left margin of each page, and also on the upper part of each left margin appears the same violet ink smudge accompanied by the written words 'Gabina Raquel' with 'by Lourdes Samonte' underneath it. 2. The proponent's evidence is to the effect that the decedent allegedly instructed Atty. Agbunag to drat her will and brought to her on January 1950. With all the witnesses with her and the lawyer, the decedent affixed her thumbmark at the foo...

Testate Estate of Cagro v. Cagro Digest

Testate Estate of Cagro vs. Cagro G.R. L-5826 Facts:  1. The case is an appeal interposed by the oppositors from a decision of the CFI of Samar which admitted to probate a will allegedly executed by Vicente Cagro who died in Pambujan, Samar on Feb. 14, 1949. 2. The appellants insisted that the will is defective because the attestation was not signed by the witnesses at the bottom although the page containing the same was signed by the witnesses on the left hand margin. 3. Petitioner contended that the signatures of the 3 witnesses on the left hand margin conform substantially to law and may be deemed as their signatures to the attestation clause. Issue: Whether or not the will is valid HELD: Will is not valid. The attestation clause is a memorandum of the facts attending the execution of the will. It is required by law to be made by the attesting witnesses and it must necessarily bear their signatures. An unsigned attestation clause cannot be considered a...